It happened at a union carbide subsidiary pesticide plant in the city of bhopal, india. It was difficult to understand how a landmark judgement disposing of the case for compensation was suddenly delivered by the supreme court when it was only an appeal against the interim order which was. View bhopal gas tragedy research papers on academia. The case discusses the role played by union carbide corporation. Union of india, 1986 mc mehta filed a public interest litigation for escape of poisonous gases by a plant in bhopal. Over 500,000 people were exposed to methyl isocyanate mic gas. The bhopal disaster of 1984 university of new mexico. Dear all, please see the attached bhopal gas tragedy video.
Victims of the 1984 bhopal gas tragedy have filed an appeal in a higher court here contesting a lower courts decision that union carbide corporation cannot be sued for the ongoing contamination. Team, attached the pdf copy judgement of bhopal gas tragedy. The bhopal gas tragedy is the worst air pollution episode ever witnessed in india. This was the beginning of years of legal machinations in which the ethical implications of the tragedy and its affect on bhopals people were largely ignored. It occurred in december of 1984 at bhopal in madhya pradesh.
A quarter century after the worlds worst industrial disaster killed over 15000 people, a bhopal. Peterson revised march 20, 2009 during the night of 23 december 1984, a leak of some 40 tons of methyl isocyanate mic gas mixed with unknown other gasses from a chemical plant owned and operated by union carbide india limited, a. The judgement is actually ultravires the existing law which makes it even more controversial. In case of bp leak in the gulf of mexico, an amount of 20 billion dollars was compensated for just 11 people who were killed. The bhopal disaster or bhopal gas tragedy was an industrial accident. This paper can be downloaded in pdf format from ielrcs website at. I had previously thought before reading this case that this accident draws many parallels to the bhopal gas tragedy, which was a. However, arguments advanced by ucc was that since it had only a 50. Bhopal disaster simple english wikipedia, the free. The bhopal gas tragedy this case was written by sanjib dutta, icfai center for management research icmr. In my opinion the verdict on the shriram gas leak case by the supreme court was fair, balanced and adequate for many reasons.
The multinational has won and the people of india have lost. On the night of 23 december 1984, the plant released approximately 40 tonnes of toxic methyl isocyanate mic gas, exposing more than 500,000 people to toxic gases a mixture of poisonous gases flooded the city, causing. Bhopal gas peedith mahila udyog sangathan and others v. On 2121984, there was a massive escape of lethal gas from a storage tank at bhopal plant of the union carbide india ltd. Union carbide corporation vs union of india etc on 4 may, 1989. Bhopal disaster, chemical leak in 1984 in the city of bhopal, madhya pradesh state, india, during which about 45 tons of methyl isocyanate escaped from an insecticide plant. Bhopal gas tragedy and its ethical issues essay 3042 words. Bhopal, chemical incident, methyl isocyanate, respiratory disease, lung function, epidemiology contents 1. Campaigners put the death toll as high as 25,000 and say the horrific effects of the gas continue to this day. This case was created by the international dimensions of ethics education in. The bhopal gas tragedy commonly referred to as bhopal disaster was a gas leak incident in india, considered one of the worlds worst industrial catastrophes. The criminal cases against the corporation and its officials were reinstated in the final judgement. The tragedy was a result of the leak of the methyl isocyanate mic gas from the union carbide india ltd ucil plant which manufactured pesticides.
Supreme court judgement on bhopal gas tragedy india today. And this resulted in the bhopal gas tragedy, a disaster that brought about the worlds largest law suit 57. The court in this case extended the scope of article 21 and 32 of the constitution of india. It occurred on the night of 2nd3rd december 1984 at the union carbide india limited ucil pesticide plant in bhopal, madhya pradesh. The bhopal gas leak disaster symbolises the failure of the legal system in general. The union carbide factory is located in bhopal, a town in madhya pradesh. In march 1985, the indian government enacted the bhopal gas leak disaster act as a way of ensuring that claims arising from the accident would be dealt with speedily and equitably. An analysis of bhopal gas tragedy with respect to victimology and criminal negligence anshumaan bahadur this is a matter of fact that the bhopal gas tragedy is the biggest disaster india can ever witness. This report would not have come about without the support of many of the bhopal groups bhopal group for information and action, bhopal gas peedit mahila udyog sangathan, bhopal gas peedit stationery karamchari sangh, sambhavna, bhopal ki awaaz, bhopal. The fateful incident happened due to the leakage of lethal gas called methyl isocyanate mic gas from three storage tanks.
Case study series bhopal plant disaster situation summary m. Dear pawar, please share the bhopal gas tragedy materials with us if u upload here its easily reach to our members. Bhopals gas tragedy had deplored the unequal power relations between often poor or even bankrupt debtor governments and transnational corporations. The fatal gas leak at the union carbide india limited plant in bhopal in 1984 was one of the worst industrial disasters in indias history. The company involved in what became the worst industrial accident in history immediately tried to dissociate itself from legal. Ucc agreeing to satisfy any judgment rendered by an indian court as finally upheld. On the night of december 23, 1984, there was a leak of. It is intended to be used as the basis for class discussion rather than to illustrate either effective or ineffective handling of a management situation. While the petition was pending, on 4 and 6 december 1985, there was leakage of oleum gas from one of its units which caused. It was on the night of december 2, 1984, when bhopal died a million deaths.
It is considered to be the worlds worst industrial disaster. The bhopal case has come to a disturbing end in an abrupt and unprecedented manner. The bhopal gas leak tragedy that occurred at midnight of 2nd. An interim order was passed on 25220051 by which the state government was restrained from implementing its proposal of merging the bhopal gas tragedy relief and rehabilitation department with its public health and family welfare department and granting time to the state government to file an affidavit to oppose this application, if so desired. Since 1986 it has been a hot topic for discussion and the victims have still not been delivered justice. C mehta, a social activist lawyer, he sought closure for shriram industries as it was engaged in manufacturing of hazardous substances and located in a densely populated area of kirti nagar. A quarter century after the worlds worst industrial disaster killed over 15,000 people, a. A quarter century after the worlds worst industrial disaster killed over 15,000 people, a bhopal court convicted former union carbide india. The chemical, methyl isocyanate mic, that spilled out from union carbide india ltds ucils pesticide factory turned the city into a vast gas chamber. Lawyers for the victims of the 1984 bhopal poison gas disaster this week filed arguments with the u. The supreme court also directed union carbide to finance a. The bhopal disaster of 1984 indiaenvironmentportal. Bhopal gas tragedy presented by swati sudhakaran background of union carbide india ltd ucil ucil, built in 1969, which was the indian subsidiary of union carbide corporation ucc, ucil was owned 51% by union carbide corporation and 49% of indian investors which include indian government controlled banks and the indian public holdings. Court of appeals for the second circuit that the companywas continuing to foul local wells from its plant located in the areathe appeal comes more than a year after a new york federal district court found that union carbide.
Us court rejects case against union carbide july 01, 2014 never expect this from us. Bhopals tragedy the indian government says some 3,500 people died within days and more than 15,000 in the years since. The full judgement of the bhopal gas leak case rediff. This case was written by sanjib dutta, icfai center for management research. Later, as the deadly cloud slowly drifted in the cool night air through streets in. The case gives an overview of the bhopal gas tragedy. Union carbides investigation a union carbide corporation ucc investigation team arrived in bhopal within days of the incident, but could not begin its investigation because the indian central bureau of investigation cbi had taken control of and sealed the plant. The bhopal gas tragedy is, till date, the worlds worst industrial disaster. The bhopal gas tragedy introduction free management. It remains to be seen whether the union of india will pursue its case any further. The bhopal disaster, also referred to as the bhopal gas tragedy, was a gas leak incident on the night of 23 december 1984 at the union carbide india limited ucil pesticide plant in bhopal, madhya pradesh, india. In the days after the gas leak, anderson was arrested and then released on bail by the madhya pradesh police on december 7, 1984.
1246 35 82 105 716 111 1509 578 654 1294 249 1490 472 1046 316 1241 204 351 916 783 1512 1412 318 929 690 1500 607 1109 1508 353 873 159 491 969 977 232 1466 1192 87 931 1181 1421 1429 1083 1029 1414 332